The Past as Present
Forging Contemporary Identities Through History
Échec de l'ajout au panier.
Échec de l'ajout à la liste d'envies.
Échec de la suppression de la liste d’envies.
Échec du suivi du balado
Ne plus suivre le balado a échoué
Acheter pour 22,85 $
Aucun mode de paiement valide enregistré.
Nous sommes désolés. Nous ne pouvons vendre ce titre avec ce mode de paiement
-
Narrateur(s):
-
Manisha Sethi
-
Auteur(s):
-
Romila Thapar
À propos de cet audio
Understanding our past is of critical importance to our present. Many popularly held views about the past need to be critically inquired into before they can be taken as historical. For instance, what was the aftermath of the raid on the Somanatha temple? Which of us is Aryan or Dravidian? Why is it important for Indian society to be secular? When did communalism as an ideology gain a foothold in the country? How and when did our patriarchal mindset begin to support a culture of violence against women? Why are the fundamentalists so keen to rewrite history textbooks?
The answers to these and similar questions have been disputed and argued about ever since they were first posed. Distinguished historian Romila Thapar has investigated, analyzed and interpreted the history that underlies such questions throughout her career; now, in this book, through a series of incisive essays she argues that it is of critical importance for the past to be carefully and rigorously explained, if the legitimacy of our present, wherever it derives from the past, is to be portrayed as accurately as possible. This is especially pertinent given the attempts by unscrupulous politicians, religious fundamentalists and their ilk to try and misrepresent and willfully manipulate the past in order to serve their present-day agendas.
An essential and necessary book at a time when sectarianism, bogus 'nationalism' and the muddying of historical facts are increasingly becoming a feature of our public, private and intellectual lives.
Romila Thapar is one of the most important indian academics writing today. Well-researched and thoroughly accessible, this volume is sure to become essential listening for those interested in Indian history and religion. It includes her experience of writing history textbooks for school, analysis of ancient history and interpretations of the epics, and the role history plays in contemporary politics.
©2014 Romila Thapar (P)2016 Audible, Inc.Ce que les auditeurs disent de The Past as Present
Moyenne des évaluations de clientsÉvaluations – Cliquez sur les onglets pour changer la source des évaluations.
-
Au global
-
Performance
-
Histoire
- Hermes
- 2022-05-19
Get to the point and with specifics faster!
I tried numerous ways of listening to this book and just couldn't get into it. I gave up shortly after the beginning of part two.
Overall = Content: 3/5, too vague
Performance = Narration: 2/5, I found her high-pitch nasal voice that started every sentence with a rising tone very aesthetically annoying
Story = Writing: 2/5, long sentences that don't say much
The introduction went on forever. I admit that I got only to the beginning of part two, but I became fed up. Very dry listening on what could be a fascinating subject. Somehow political more than academic. I became irritated when the author failed to name dates, personalities and sources of specific historical misunderstandings she mentioned. Everything was far too general as if she was afraid to name names. There was no "on date X, in an editorial by Y in publication X claimed that 'quote'. I take issue with the facts of the matter because archaeological and DNA evidence has proven that...", etc
One of the most frustrating books I have ever paid for on Audible. This book strikes me as philosophy, not history. But it's not even real philosophy! It is unsubstantiated opinion.
Context: At university in my youth I studied Indian religion and philosophy. I have been to India many times.
Update at chapter 9 in book (chapter 13 in Audible version): Well, *finally* the guts of the book! It does get much better departing from my criticisms above except the narrator. So I found the audio book unsalvagable. I might pick up the text version.
Un problème est survenu. Veuillez réessayer dans quelques minutes.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.
Vous avez donné votre avis sur cette évaluation.