In this episode of the You Can Mentor podcast, Zach Garza interviews Mike McGarry, a seasoned youth pastor and theologian, about the critical role of mentoring in youth ministry. They delve into the importance of presence in mentoring relationships, discipleship, and how to assess a mentee’s spiritual relationship with God. Mike highlights the significance of identity in Christ, emphasizing the need for youth to understand their role as image bearers of God. The conversation also explores the challenges and strategies of mentoring youth in a spiritual context, touching on the awkwardness often felt in initiating conversations about faith, selecting the right biblical texts, and practical tips for overcoming barriers to spiritual discussions.

Throughout their dialogue, Zach and Mike stress that mentoring requires intentionality, authenticity, and vulnerability, especially when it comes to building relationships that foster spiritual growth. They discuss how mentors can guide young people, particularly those without reliable adult figures in their lives, by providing meaningful affirmation, support, and insights into Christian doctrine. The conversation highlights that spiritual vitality is essential for a healthy faith and that every youth should have a mentor to help them navigate their relationship with God.

--

Takeaways:

• The ministry of presence is foundational in youth mentoring.
• Building relationships is key to effective youth ministry.
• Discipleship is a slow process requiring intentionality.
• Understanding Christian doctrine is essential for youth.
• Spiritual vitality is crucial for a healthy faith.
• Mentors should assess their mentees’ spiritual relationships.
• Identity in Christ is central to mentoring.
• Prayer should be the first step in mentoring.
• Authenticity and vulnerability strengthen mentoring relationships.
• Every youth should have a mentor guiding them in faith.
• Mentors should highlight positive traits in mentees that reflect Christ.
• Opening the Bible can help ease awkward conversations about faith.
• It's important to meet with mentees with the expectation of discussing faith.
• Awkwardness in spiritual conversations is common but can be overcome.
• Asking about prayer requests can lead to deeper discussions.
• Choosing engaging biblical texts is crucial for effective mentoring.
• Insecurities can hinder mentorship; submit them to God.
• Mentors should avoid comparing themselves to other adults in mentees' lives.
• Meaningful affirmation is more impactful than empty flattery.
• Mentors play a vital role in guiding youth towards a relationship with God.

--

Chapters

00:00 Introduction to Youth Ministry and Mentoring
09:48 Understanding Discipleship and Spiritual Growth
21:58 Identity and Being Created in God's Image
28:38 Navigating Mentorship Awkwardness
36:16 Choosing the Right Biblical Texts
45:41 The Unique Role of a Mentor

--
It would mean the WORLD to us if you would leave a 5 star rating on our pod so we can reach more people! Scroll down to the bottom the You Can Mentor page on Apple Podcasts and click "Write Review". On Spotify, go to our page, click the three dots next to the admin wheel, and hit "Rate Show". Thank you!
Also, check out our National Christian Mentoring Gathering, which is April 16-18, 2025 in Colorado Springs, Colorado.
Learn more about all we do at www.youcanmentor.com