On Christmas Eve of 1945 five children perished in a tragic house fire...or did they...what really happened to the Sodder children terrible that night??

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

This week we are doing another one of Marlene's suggestions andddd it's a sad one. We talk about the devastating story of Matthew Shepard.

If you can take anything away from this episode, let it be to remember to just keep love and kindness in your hearts. Happy Valentine's everyone. <3

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

Once upon a time...there was a creepy ass forest in Germany. Hear about all the spooky happenings that go on in the Black Forest on this week's episode!

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

Take a hike! Up to the top of Mount Rubidoux where a whole bunch of spooky stuff is happening. Hear all about it in this week's episode!

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

This week we are visiting Port Townsend, Washington. We'll make a few stops and meet more than a few ghosts!

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

This week Marlene and Alyssa talk about the Kentucky meat shower! And yes, it's just as weird as it sounds.

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

Welcome to the first anniversary episode of What's Your Favorite Scary Story?! We're so grateful we've gotten to put out episodes for you guys for the past year and we hope that we get to do it for many more years!

In honor of our podcast turning one, I selected one of Marlene's suggestions this week since this podcast wouldn't be possible without her! So this week we are talking about the story of Elisa Lam and the Cecil Hotel.

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send me your ideas!

HAPPY 2025! This week we talk all about the Pfister Hotel. A place you may not want to visit if you're a baseball player...find out why on this episode of What's Your Favorite Scary Story!

This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send me your ideas!