It's great, I guess

Loved the movie, which puts me the lower percentile of Star Trek geeks. Loved the book even better which I think allows me to break even, After listening, I'm an even bigger fan of the audiobook. So glad I bought it. It was a fresh look back on The Motion Picture. Mr. Petkoff does an admiral (see what I did there?) job of imitating the familiar voices of the cast in much the same way that Marc Thompson did so well in his readings of the Star Wars Thrawn trilogy audiobooks, Because most of us will have already seen the movie before listening, this rendition plays out like a producer's cut. When he hear what sounds like Kirk or Spock or McCoy in our ears saying the same words that appear in the film, we see Shatner and Nimoy and Kelley in our minds going through the motions and then going beyond the frameline to show a deeper side of their characters. In the movie, a big deal is made out of McCoy stepping out of the elevator and on to the bridge at crucial moments only to look around wordlessly then return to the elevator and leave the scene. I never understood the motivation for staging the action this way (perhaps he had some dialogue that was cut for timing). In the novel, these moments appear but Roddenberry gives McCoy the purpose and usefulness that was, I felt, wasted by Robert Wise.

One thing about this book that I should flag for future readers/listeners is that it is about as racy a Star Trek novel as you will ever encounter - at least in terms of the Original Crew. Roddenberry reminds us over and over again how beautiful and sexually alluring Lieutenant Illia is whether as a Deltan or as an alien probe (oops, did I just spoil something? Surely not after 30 years people!) After listening to certain passages, a couple of thoughts came to me...#1. Do Deltan women have any power over lesbians or is it just men? I'm only asking because Deltans seems to cast their hootchie-mama powers out into the world without a care for whom they might catch. Okay, on to #2. We've all very familiar with the form-fitting uniform that male crew members are required to wear while on duty. Once you've stuck a Deltan woman in their midsts, don't you think there'd be a 20-30ft wave of "made-you-look" boners as the men go about their starship business? All kidding aside, Roddenberry - as well as the writers and the director of the film - cares more about the male gaze than the male response. It's embarrassing to witness these wise space explorers confronted with such obvious sexual potency yet dim-wittedly ask of each other "Hmm, what do you make of that?"

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Solid adaption of a classic film.

Well acted and nothing really left out of the overall story. It would be great to have this kind of adaption on all of the TOS films.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful