• #13 | Why a Former Atheist Found Protestantism Unconvincing (Interview: Dr. Alan Fimister)

  • Feb 6 2025
  • Length: 2 hrs and 34 mins
  • Podcast

#13 | Why a Former Atheist Found Protestantism Unconvincing (Interview: Dr. Alan Fimister)

  • Summary

  • CULTIVATING SAINTS, SAGES, AND STATESMEN THROUGH THE GREAT TRADITION OF CHRISTENDOM

    In our first full-length interview, we host Dr. Alan Fimister, a renowned theologian and seminary professor, to discuss his conversion to the Catholic Faith from atheism, and why he found protestantism so unconvincing. Not only did he find it unconvincing, he concluded it played a decisive role in the rise of secularism. We also discuss issues of political theology, Christendom, and the rise of liberalism (both "left" and "right" wing varieties).

    Dr. Fimister is a member of Eternal Christendom's Advisory Board. We hope to host him as a regular guest on the Eternal Christendom Podcast. You can find his bio here: https://eternalchristendom.com/advisory-board/

    Support Eternal Christendom: https://eternalchristendom.com/become-a-patron/

    Connect with Joshua on social media

    X: https://twitter.com/JoshuaTCharles

    Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/joshuatcharles/

    Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/joshuatcharles/

    EPISODE CHAPTERS

    00:00 - Intro

    02:32 - Bio: Dr. Alan Fimister

    05:13 - Interview: Dr. Fimister's Atheist/Communist Childhood

    20:01 - Anglicanism, and the UK's "Christian" State of Apostasy

    24:17 - More of Dr. Fimister's Non-Christian Childhood

    25:38 - Dr. Fimister's Earliest Memories of the Blessed Virgin Mary

    28:52 - Dr. Fimister's First Consideration of Religion/Christianity

    35:24 - His Atheist Father Reading Him C.S. Lewis's "Chronicles of Narnia" as a Child

    36:13 - Pictures of Hell in a Friend's Family Bible

    37:50 - Asking His Mother if He Could Become Anglican

    39:13 - Attending Catholic School

    44:45 - Those Who Know the Catholic Faith is True But Don't Convert Go to Hell

    46:12 - Dr. Fimister Asks His Mother to be Baptized

    48:23 - Dr. Fimister's Favorite Biblical Character as a Child

    48:50 - Receiving a Beautiful Gift from His Catholic Teacher, and Being Baptized

    51:24 - Why So Many Catholic Friends Fell Away from the Faith

    56:14 - Why Catholicism Was the Only Viable Option

    01:01:09 - The Rise of the "Celebrity" Papacy

    01:05:04 - Why Protestantism Was Not Convincing

    01:11:00 - Facing Protestant Opposition at University

    01:12:33 - Is Catholicism Pelagian or Semi-Pelagian?

    01:15:36 - Valid Protestant Points on Good Works, and the Church's Actual Teaching

    01:26:24 - Why Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy are Fairly Easy to Refute

    01:31:11 - Protestantism and the Rise of Secularism

    01:37:08 - Why an Infallible Magisterium is Necessary, and Not Above Scripture

    01:49:09 - How Protestantism Inadvertently Paved the Way for Secularism

    02:32:53 - Conclusion

    Listen on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/eternal-christendom-podcast/id1725000526

    Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3HoTTco6oJtApc21ggVevu

    Show more Show less

What listeners say about #13 | Why a Former Atheist Found Protestantism Unconvincing (Interview: Dr. Alan Fimister)

Average Customer Ratings

Reviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.